WEEKLY SALE: 25% off home decor (ex: silk flowers, gnomes) good through 2/17/2024******** 50% off all baby clothes

Custom Cakes

We offer a variety of custom cakes flavors and designs for all of life's precious moments. All of our cakes are carefully decorated with whichever signature buttercream flavor the client desires. Our cake decorators have honed their skills to create unique and beautiful buttercream masterpieces!

Pricing Varies

Our pricing varies based on size, filling type, and the level of intricacy in decoration. Some designs or themes require more time to make, meaning it may cost more. We have base prices for our cakes listed in the ‘Pricing’ section below. If you work with one of our decorators at the shop they will be able to give you a personalized quote based on your order request.

** Gluten Free and Vegan Options available for special order
Interested in ordering a custom cake?
REQUEST QUOTE
  • CAKE FLAVORS
  • FILLING FLAVORS
  • FROSTING FLAVORS
  • PRICING

Classic Cake Flavors

Vanilla

Chocolate

Red Velvet

Lemon

Almond

Specialty Cake Flavors

Refer to the cupcake section for our specialty flavors

Filling Flavors

Ganache

Raspberry

Strawberry

Lemon Curd

Dulce de Leche (Caramel)

Blueberry

Classic Frosting Flavors

Vanilla Buttercream

Chocolate Buttercream

Almond Buttercream

Premium Frosting Flavors

Berry (Raspberry, Strawberry, Blackberry) Buttercream

Oreo Cookie Buttercream

Whipped Peanut Butter Buttercream

Round Cakes

Sheet Cakes

Classic Cake Flavors

Vanilla

Chocolate

Red Velvet

Lemon

Almond

Specialty Cake Flavors

Refer to the cupcake section for our specialty flavors

Filling Flavors

Ganache

Raspberry

Strawberry

Lemon Curd

Dulce de Leche (Caramel)

Blueberry

Classic Frosting Flavors

Vanilla Buttercream

Chocolate Buttercream

Almond Buttercream

Premium Frosting Flavors

Berry (Raspberry, Strawberry, Blackberry) Buttercream

Oreo Cookie Buttercream

Whipped Peanut Butter Buttercream

Round Cakes

Sheet Cakes

FAQs

Yes. We do offer tastings for a cost of $20.00. Included in this cost is a selection of 4 cupcakes from our bakery case the day of the tasting appointment. If the couple chooses 3 Schweet Sisters for their wedding desserts the $20.00 will be deducted from their final invoice.

No. All of our cakes need to be pre-ordered and require a minimum of 5 day notice.

We use 100% Wisconsin butter for our buttercream. Before serving our cakes allow them a minimum of 2 hours to come to room temperature.

No. We do not use fondant for covering of our cakes or for decorations. All of our designs are completed with using buttercream.

We have listed an estimated serving amount next to each of our cakes. Note, this is an estimation due to varying ways to cut a cake.

Yes. We do offer tiered cakes in varying sizes. This requires a direct conversation to one of our cake decorators for additional information. The largest tiered cake we offer is a 4 Tier Cake.